REVIEW – Good Luck with That by Kristan Higgins

Good Luck with That

Expected publication: August 7, 2018 by Berkley Books


I know this book isn’t out until August. However, after reading the description and some recent reviews, I decided I had to read it right away.

And I’m really glad I did.

Georgia, Marley, and Emerson met at Camp Copperbrook, a weight-loss camp when they were in their teens. Now they are almost 35 years old. Georgia and Marley have been contacted by Emerson who asks to see them. Emerson knows she’s dying and wants to see her best friends one last time.

When they see her they are both shocked at how ill she is and how heavy she has become. They feel guilty that they hadn’t kept in better contact. They wonder why she didn’t reach out for help from them but deep down they know why….it was because Emerson felt ashamed. And when they visit her for the last time she hands them an envelope “To be opened after my funeral”.

After Emerson’s funeral, they open the envelope and are surprised it’s just one page long. They recognize the paper though…it’s a list from their time at Camp. A list they made called “Things We’ll Do When We’re Skinny”. It says things like – eat dessert in public, hold hands with a cute guy, shop at a store for regular people, etc….   These were all things that felt out of reach for them when they were young and overweight. Things they felt only thin girls got to enjoy.  Their conversations often had the words “When I’m skinny,  I’m going to….”

Marley is now a personal chef who delivers home-cooked meals to a variety of different people. Her clients love her. Marley comes across as happy …all the time. But is she truly happy? Or is it just an act she puts on to hide her pain? “The ache of feeling half of a pair instead of a whole person.”

Georgia left her job at a law firm four years before to become a nursery school teacher. Being overweight is unforgivable in Georgia’s family. Her brother and mother NEVER let her forget it. Georgia had been married but was unable to accept the love her husband offered.

Marley and Georgia decide they will try to complete the list Emerson left for them.

But will they realize what Emerson was really trying to tell them? What she wanted for her best friends more than anything else?

Interspersed throughout the novel are passages from Emerson’s diary. It includes things that happened when she was a child as well as the life she had been living over the last four years. Honestly, parts of the book were painful to read, especially the first few chapters and Emerson’s diary.  I felt for all of the characters. I could relate to a lot of what they were going through. I think a lot of people will. I have struggled with my weight but I don’t think you have to be overweight to understand.

I don’t agree with how people have attacked the author (in most cases WITHOUT HAVING READ THE BOOK). You don’t have to like every book you read, we’re all different. You don’t have to read the book. But attacking the author and telling others not to read it (especially if you haven’t read it) is a bit much in my opinion. Some reviewers felt that Kristan Higgins shouldn’t write about an issue she knows nothing about. Number one: We don’t know what the author (or someone close to them) may have struggled with in life. Number two: Most authors who write about serial killers aren’t serial killers so does that mean they don’t have the right to write about one?

In my opinion, this book was AWESOME.

Yes, it’s a book about weight and body image. However, it’s also about love, the bonds of friendship, relationships, self-acceptance, and other important issues.

I love the way the author writes. The relationships between many of the characters felt genuine. It’s also obvious the author has done her research. Like I said, some of the book is painful…I cried. But there was a LOT of the book that had me laughing out loud (seriously there was some crossing and knocking on wood, a spa trip and a magic show that almost had me in stitches).

There are definitely some vile characters who say some horrible things (just like in real life). However, there are also many kind, thoughtful, fantastic characters…including some of the most adorable four-year-olds ever. Kristan Higgins strikes an excellent balance between seriousness and humor.

Good Luck With That” was a fantastic read. A deeply moving and satisfying novel by an excellent author.

I’d like to thank Berkley Books and Kristan Higgins for giving me the opportunity to read this book in exchange for my honest review.


22 thoughts on “REVIEW – Good Luck with That by Kristan Higgins

  1. Perfectly said Deanna! I agree with you 100% and was outraged when people were leaving one star reviews and posting nasty comments before the book was even published.

    I immediately requested it and haven’t had a chance to read it yet but I knew this author would treat the subject matter with sensitivity and do it while writing an entertaining heartfelt story, regardless of the weight of the characters. I’m so glad you loved it 😊

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thank you so much, Jan! It really was so disrespectful for people to rate and comment without even reading it. I’m so glad that you requested it and I can’t wait to hear your thoughts. I hope you love it too!!! ❤


  2. Bravo! I haven’t read this yet, but I was lucky enough to get a copy and I can’t wait! But I completely 100% agree with you as far as people bashing the book, especially if they have not read the book!
    Additionally you do not need to be overweight to have body image issues, trust me!💜

    Liked by 2 people

  3. Excellent review, Deanna. I agree with you wholeheartedly. How can people trash a book so completely without having read it first? I’m so glad that Edelweiss approved me for this book so I can read it for myself and analyze it. From what I’ve read and seen of Kristan Higgins around the blogosphere I can’t imagine she’d ever write anything intentionally hurtful. She’s an excellent writer and I’m looking forward to reading this one. Thanks for reviewing.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Wonderful review!! I love what you said about the negative reviews! I read those before getting my copy of the book (which I can’t wait to read!!) and I was appalled! I can’t believe people would be so nasty. Obviously I haven’t read the book, but I agree no author should be dragged threw the mud. I’ve enjoyed Higgins books, and I’m sure I’ll love this one.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. […] OwlBeSatReading – The Diary of a Bookseller by Shaun Bythell Cleopatra Loves Books – Snap by Belinda Bauer Novel Deelights – Nineteen Letters by Jodi Perry Book Literati Book Reviews – The Burning Chambers by Kate Mosse What Cathy Read Next – The Million Dollar Duchesses by Julie Ferry Taking On A World of Words – The Nightingale by Kristin Hannah Dee’s Rad Reads and Reviews – Good Luck With That by Kristan Higgins […]

    Liked by 1 person

  6. “Most authors who write about serial killers aren’t serial killers so does that mean they don’t have the right to write about one?” Exactly! Well said! I get so fed up with people telling authors they should only write about their own personal experiences. It’s supposed to be a creative art, after all.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. I am shocked to hear that there are people attacking the authors. Since when does fiction have to be based on personal experiences. That is just a wrong assumption. This book sounds amazing. Can’t wait to read it.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s